As a Hilton Varsity Baseball Player, Scott was a three-time All Greater Rochester (AGR) Honoree, earning All-County and All-State Honors each year. He went on to play collegiate baseball for St. John Fisher College, as first baseman and cleanup hitter. As a four-time All-Conference and All-Region player, he was a proud member of the 2016 team which won the regional championship and clinched a World Series spot for the first time in school history. He was named Empire 8 and NY Region Rookie of Year in 2015 and Player of Year in 2017. He finished his senior season by leading the conference in several categories, while also leaving his mark on the Fisher baseball program as the all-time career leader for Homeruns, Doubles and RBIs, also tying for hits. He received the St. John Fisher Athletics Male Career Athlete of the Year award in 2018.